They must be really frightened. They’ve rolled out the big guns.
After years of advising each other “Don’t listen to Dr, Amy,” they’ve turned to advising the general public not to listen to me. How else to explain Jennifer Blocks’s charming collection of ad hominems masquerading as an article of Slate. Entitled How to Scare Women, the piece carries the subtitle “Did a Daily Beast story on the dangers of home birth rely too heavily on the views of one activist?”
The piece in The Daily Beast to which Block refers is Home Birth: Increasingly Popular but Dangerous, which included the latest statistics of homebirth deaths as well as stories of two terrible, senseless, entirely preventable deaths. Block more or less dismisses the stories, but doesn’t even bother to dismiss the statistics. She can’t; they’re accurate and damning as she surely knows. So instead she tries to discredit me in the hope that she can divert the attention of homebirth advocates from the data itself. It’s a pretty despicable tactic, especially when you consider that it depends on the belief/hope that homebirth advocates are so gullible and unsophisticated that they cannot tell them difference between the two.
Fortunately, it addition rehearsing the same old ad hominems that are so silly that I have been satirizing them for years (She let her license lapse! She quite writing for Science Based Medicine!), Block helpfully links to a variety of blog posts that I have written. I’m not sure why she did it, because it thoroughly undercuts her efforts to discredit me by giving readers access to what I have actually written. I’m not sure whether she thinks less of me or her readers; me because she doesn’t find the pieces persuasive or her readers because she assumes that they won’t read them, understand them, and be convinced by them.
I left a comment on the post:
I suppose I should be flattered that Ms. Block believes that women decide whether or not homebirth is safe depends on what they think about me. I, on the other hand, feel very strongly that women are capable of looking at data and scientific evidence for themselves and my chief task is simply to make it accessible to them.If you get past the various ad hominem attacks on me, you may note that Ms. Block has not challenged the fact that the latest CDC data shows that homebirth with a non-nurse midwife has a mortality rate 600% higher than comparable risk hospital birth. She has not challenged the high and rising rate of perinatal death at planned homebirths attended by licensed homebirths, rates that are double or triple the rate for Colorado as a whole, including premature babies and high risk women.
Women have a right to give birth at home, but they can’t make an informed decision if they don’t have complete and accurate information. Ms. Block is welcome to continue to write about me; I’ll keep writing about the data and I’ll keep trusting women to decide for themselves how to act on that data.
Jennifer Block and I do agree on one thing however; the article in The Daily Beast is scary. The scary part, though, is the mass of data that shows that homebirth with a non-nurse midwife dramatically increases the risk of neonatal death. It is deeply unfortunate, that Block, like most professional homebirth advocates, chooses to ignore that data and resorts to what amounts to little more than name calling in attempt to get others to ignore it as well.
I have a suggestion for how we might resolve the impasse. I have repeatedly challenged Jennifer Block to publicly debate the safery of homebirth. Slate could serve as the forum for a print debate about the state, national, and international statistics on homebirth, and the growing body of scientific evidence. Would the folks at Slate be willing? How about it, Jennifer? I’m ready any time; how about you?
Trackbacks/Pingbacks
Links…
Webpages of interest we’ve a url to…
International Customers Machine overview…
be sure to head to the internet pages we follow, like this an individual precise, due to the fact it signifies our picks in the net…
Web pages you’ll want to take a look at…
underneath you’ll find the url to some web pages that we consider it’s best to have a look at…
It is best to check this out…
Web-sites of interest we have a hyperlink to…
Recommeneded internet sites…
The following are some within the web pages we endorse for our website visitors…
Blogs ou really should be reading…
Listed here is often a remarkable Blog site You might Acquire effective that we Promote You to observe…
Test this out…
which is the end of the content. Right here you will get some sites that we imagine you are going to take pleasure in, just just click the back links around…
Check out this out…
that is the conclusion of this piece of writing. Here you’ll unearth some online sites that we assume you’ll recognize, just simply click the inbound links through…
Over the internet Brief article…
The knowledge pointed out inside of the content are some of the greatest readily available…
Read through was engaging, stay in touch…
please head to the internet sites we use, such as this one, as it signifies our picks in the online…
Cambridgeshire wedding photographer…
an example of our site visitors a short while ago proposed the next website…
Online sites we Like…
Nearly every once in a very even when we prefer weblogs that we read through. Listed down below will be the hottest online sites that we determine…
International Website visitors Machine assessment…
you should stop by the web webpages we stick to, like this a person special, as it represents our picks in the world wide web…
Gems with the word wide web…
highly handful of websites that come about to generally be in depth under, from our point of view are definitely well worthy of checking out…
Check out was fascinating, stay in contact…
be sure to see the websites we comply with, among them this one, as it represents our picks with the web…
Cool webpages…
we arrived throughout a awesome resource site you will probably appreciate. Consider a look if you’d like…
Interesting websites…
we came across a fantastic information site that you just can enjoy. Take a glance in order for you…
On the internet Article…
The knowledge brought up while in the brief article are some of the greatest available…
International Traffic Device report…
be sure to stop by the net pages we follow, like this a person precise, due to the fact it represents our picks within the word wide web…
Go through was engaging, remain in touch…
please go to the sites we comply with, which include this 1, because it signifies our picks within the world-wide-web…
Customer suggestions…
undoubtedly one of our readers not long ago proposed the next site…
Speediest process to burn stomach fat rapid…
Each the moment inside a after we choose for blogs that we look at. Outlined beneath will be the most present websites that we decide for…
Investigate this out…
that’s the conclude of the document. The following you are going to locate some online sites that we suppose you will take pleasure in, just just click the one way links through…
Great web-sites…
we came throughout a nice webpage that you just may delight in. Require a glance if you’d like…
Check out this out…
that is certainly the conclusion of the content. Right here you are going to acquire some sites that we suspect you are going to recognize, just simply click the links above…
Investigate this out…
that’s the conclude of the document. The following you are going to locate some online sites that we suppose you will take pleasure in, just just click the one way links through…
Swiftest option to melt away belly weight speedy…
Just about every once inside of a once we choose for blogs that we read. Listed beneath are classified as the most existing websites that we opt for…
Amazing webpages…
we arrived across a nice web page that you simply could have fun with. Take a glance if you’d like…
Amazing website…
consistently a big admirer of linking to bloggers that I like but do not get yourself a number of backlink adore from…
Cambridgeshire marriage ceremony photographer…
amongst our visitors a short when ago advocated the following web-site…
Superb websites…
consistently a giant fan of linking to bloggers that I love but don’t get yourself a great deal of link appreciate from…
Nice webpages…
we came throughout a fantastic web page that you just could get pleasure from. Require a glance if you would like…
Gems within the internet…
highly several internet sites that materialize to be detailed down below, from our point of view are unquestionably nicely worth checking out…
Cambridgeshire wedding ceremony photographer…
an example of our website visitors a brief at the same time back suggested the subsequent web pages…
Learn was unique, stay in touch…
be sure to pay a visit to the web pages we pursue, like this one particular, as it signifies our picks in the online…
Gems from the world wide web…
extremely couple of websites that transpire for being comprehensive below, from our standpoint are definitely very well truly worth checking out…
Make sure you examine this out…
Online websites of interest we’ve a hyperlink to…
Dreary Day…
It was a dreary day listed here now, so I just took to messing close to online and located…
Internet sites we Like…
Any once in the at the same time we decide on blogs that we study. Detailed under are classified as the most popular online sites that we choose…
Using the web Piece of writing…
The knowledge talked about from the guide are a few of the greatest accessible…
Dreary Day…
It absolutely was a dreary day the following today, so I just took to messing about on the web and found…
Learn was unique, stay in touch…
be sure to pay a visit to the web pages we pursue, like this one particular, as it signifies our picks in the online…
Customer suggestions…
among our website visitors not long ago encouraged the next blog…
Webpages we Like…
Each and every when in a whilst we select blogs that we read. Outlined under are classified as the hottest internet sites that we decide upon…
Learn was attention-grabbing, keep in contact…
make sure you explore the web-sites we comply with, which includes this a person, while it represents our picks with the internet…
Brilliant web site…
enough time to go through or head to the website content or web-sites we’ve got connected to down below the…
Recommeneded online websites…
Below are some of your sites we highly recommend for our people…
Wonderful blog…
the time to look at or have a look at the information or internet sites we’ve got connected to down below the…
On the web Post…
The data described inside post are a few of the greatest offered…
Wonderful article! This is the kind of information that are supposed to be shared across the web. Disgrace on the seek engines for no longer positioning this submit upper! Come on over and consult with my website . Thank you =)…
Greetings! Very helpful advice in this particular article! It’s the little changes that make the largest changes. Thanks a lot for sharing!…
Online websites price checking out…
the following are a few one way links to internet sites that we link to due to the fact we think that they are really worthy of checking out…
Dreary Day…
It absolutely was a dreary day the following today, so I just took to messing about on the web and found…
Wonderful web-sites…
we came across a neat web-site that you may perhaps savor. Get a glance in order for you…
Fascinating online sites…
we came throughout a nice web page you would possibly relish. Require a look if you would like…
Examine was exciting, keep in contact…
please have a look at the sites we go along with, this includes this a single, due to the fact it represents our picks from the online…
Dreary Day…
It was a dreary day listed here today, so I just took to messing roughly online and identified…
Customer recommendations…
among our site visitors fairly recently suggested the subsequent web-site…
Gems with the on-line…
rather several websites that come to pass to get precise underneath, from our standpoint are undoubtedly well well worth trying out…
Read through was exciting, remain in contact…
you should have a look at the sites we adopt, like this a single, as it signifies our picks from your internet…
Fantastic web-site…
enough time to examine or explore the subject matter or online websites we’ve got linked to below the…
Fantastic sites…
we came throughout a interesting resource site which you will probably take pleasure in. Require a glance if you would like…
Amazing web-site…
time to examine or head over to the website content or internet sites now we have related to down below the…
Internet sites we Like…
Nearly every as soon as in the though we choose blogs that we learn. Outlined below would be the newest sites that we opt for…
Fantastic sites…
we came throughout a interesting resource site which you will probably take pleasure in. Require a glance if you would like…
Browse was exciting, keep in touch…
you should see the web pages we pursue, together with this a single, since it represents our picks through the web…
Weblogs ou should really be looking through…
Right here is definitely a Amazing Blogging site You would possibly Acquire Interesting that we Inspire You…
International Visitors Device report…
please go to the net webpages we abide by, such as this a single specific, due to the fact it signifies our picks from the word wide web…
Hyperlinks…
Online sites of interest we have a backlink to…
On line Short article…
The information described within the report are a few of the greatest accessible…
Speediest strategy to melt away stomach fat rapidly…
Each individual when inside of a when we decide for blogs that we examine. Listed underneath will be the most up-to-date websites that we choose for…
Weblogs ou should certainly be browsing…
The following is really a Superb Web site You can Come across Intriguing that we Stimulate You…
Sources…
test underneath, are a few absolutely unrelated web pages to ours, nonetheless, they’re most reliable sources that we use…
Dreary Day…
It absolutely was a dreary day below now, so I just took to messing approximately online and identified…
Dreary Day…
It was a dreary day listed here now, so I just took to messing close to online and located…
Online websites we think you might want to see…
while online websites we backlink to beneath are considerably not related to ours, we sense they are literally worth a experience, so use a look…
Hi there! I simply want to give you a huge thumbs up for the excellent information you’ve got right here on this post. I’ll be coming back to your web site for more soon….
Hello! I simply want to give you a big thumbs up for the great information you have got here on this post. I am returning to your site for more soon….
Trendy webpages…
we arrived throughout a awesome website which you might possibly like. Require a look if you want…
Over the internet Brief article…
The knowledge described inside the post are a few of the greatest on hand…
Salvador Cochrum…
we came across a trendy blog which you could acquire satisfaction in. Consider a research once you want…
You’ve made some really good points there. I checked on the net for additional information about the issue and found most individuals will go along with your views on this website….
Great post. I will be going through many of these issues as well…..
Internet websites you ought to go to…
down below you are going to find the hyperlink to some web-sites that we suppose you must head over to…
Dreary Day…
It was a dreary day listed here right now, so I just took to messing roughly online and located…
Via the internet Report…
The information pointed out in the brief article are some of the greatest attainable…
Pretty! This has been an extremely wonderful post. Thank you for supplying this information….
A motivating discussion is worth comment. I do believe that you need to publish more about this subject, it may not be a taboo matter but typically people do not discuss these subjects. To the next! Many thanks!!…
Over the internet Brief article…
The knowledge described inside the post are a few of the greatest on hand…
One way links…
Web sites of curiosity now we have a link to…
Check out this out…
that is certainly the conclude of this content. Listed here you will unearth some webpages that we suppose you will appreciate, just click on the back links more than…
Online Article…
The data mentioned on the report are some of the best on hand…
Speediest process to burn stomach fat rapid…
Each the moment inside a after we choose for blogs that we look at. Outlined beneath will be the most present websites that we decide for…
Gems variety the internet…
incredibly very few web sites that happen to be comprehensive under, from our standpoint are definitely properly really worth looking at…
Blogs ou have to be examining…
Listed here is really a Superb Blog You could Identify Interesting that we Encourage You…
Title…
[...]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a few unrelated information, nonetheless truly really worth taking a search, whoa did one particular master about Mid East has got extra problerms also [...]…
Title…
[...]Every after in a when we select blogs that we study. Listed beneath would be the latest internet sites that we choose [...]…
Weblogs ou must be examining…
Below is known as a Excellent Blog page You could possibly Find Remarkable that we Inspire You…
Weblogs ou must be examining…
Below is known as a Excellent Blog page You could possibly Find Remarkable that we Inspire You…
Title…
[...]please stop by the internet sites we follow, including this one particular, because it represents our picks from the web[...]…
Fantastic websites…
we arrived throughout a wonderful online site that you just may well relish. Just take a look if you want…
Online sites we Like…
Any the moment within a while we choose weblogs that we read through. Outlined beneath are classified as the most recently released webpages that we decide upon…